<<O>>  Difference Topic RepRapElectronics (r1.5 - 26 Mar 2009 - ZachSmith)

META TOPICPARENT RepStrap_1_0_Seedling

RepRap Electronics System

Line: 42 to 42

As the project grows, we make mistakes and learn lessons. The electronics have gradually evolved over time due to this influx of knowledge. We have tried our best to keep everything compatible, and I believe we've done a good job. Here is the current status of the various electronics setups.

Changed:
<
<

PIC Based Electronics

>
>

Generation 3: Sanguino Based Electronics


Pros

Changed:
<
<
  • software that currently works
  • relatively large base of users who have them built and are actively using them.
  • modular design at network level
>
>
  • easy programming through Arduino
  • rock solid compiler (avr-gcc)
  • chopper-style stepper driving
  • ADC temperature readings
  • based on other open source projects (Arduino, avr-gcc)
  • modular on network and peripheral level
  • more powerful atmega644p chip
  • rs485 comms network for robust comms
  • multiple, modular tool system
  • simplified connectors / wiring

Cons

Changed:
<
<
  • lack of easy programing
  • lack of a reliable compiler (SDCC issues)
  • very rough stepper driving
  • poor temperature measurement, etc.
>
>
  • Software still under development
  • Majority of parts are SMT only

Changed:
<
<

Arduino Based Electronics

>
>

Generation 2: Arduino Based Electronics


Pros

Line: 71 to 77

Cons

Deleted:
<
<
  • Software still under development

  • More circuit boards to deal with
  • more centralized to one processor (may be pro or con depending on the person)
  • Shortage of I/O pins (though the sanguino addresses this)
Added:
>
>

Generation 1: PIC Based Electronics

Pros

  • software that currently works
  • relatively large base of users who have them built and are actively using them.
  • modular design at network level

Cons

  • lack of easy programing
  • lack of a reliable compiler (SDCC issues)
  • very rough stepper driving
  • poor temperature measurement, etc.
View topic | Diffs | r1.5 | > | r1.4 | > | r1.3 | More
Revision r1.4 - 20 Sep 2008 - 07:22 - VikOlliver
Revision r1.5 - 26 Mar 2009 - 21:20 - ZachSmith