Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

"CAD" files vs CAM files - a designer's plea

Posted by Nether10 
Re: "CAD" files vs CAM files - a designer's plea
January 20, 2011 10:46PM
One thing that hasn't been taken into account in any of this "STEP is more accurate than .stl" debate is location. Because .stls are predicated on production, part of the .stl format is location. All valid .stls are translated to be located in the positive coordinate octant. Every user, even if he or she is using the same application as the user sitting next to them, can have their STEP object located anywhere. When the user exports .stl, triangulation can often be different depending on the 3D space location of the .STEP object, ie if you've got a .STEP model of Mendel, and export .stl of two of the frame vertices, it's likely the triangulation of them will be different. If you edit a native .stl with booleans, there's also going to almost inevitably be subdivision along the conjoined boundaries. So STEP might be considered to be "more accurate", but given the built-in inaccuracies of repraps and the outcomes of conversions, none of that's really going to be sustained unless .stl is abandoned for STEP. Given the likely cost and inconvenience of that, and the dramas that'd erupt if anyone forgets to translate the object and their reprap tries to reset all axes to a point on the 33rd floor three kilometres away, I don't think there's a benefit that compels.
Re: "CAD" files vs CAM files - a designer's plea
January 21, 2011 08:32AM
Hmmm. It is true that the RP processes are not as precise as the geometry generated in CAD. But the inaccuracies in the CAD models will be added to the inaccuracy of the printers. So it seems to me that it would be good practice to keep things precise as far along the tool chain as we can, in order to achieve the best possible prints. Having to make sure the model is in the positive octant seems a small price to pay for being able to make judgments about .stl precision at build time instead of design time.

None of the RepRap controller tools or part slicers perform sanity checks to make sure the .stl isn't on the 33rd floor? Huh.
Re: "CAD" files vs CAM files - a designer's plea
January 21, 2011 10:07AM
A long while ago I posted some STEP Reprap files for Alibre that were converted from some original Solidedge files.
see [www.sloan-home.co.uk]
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login