Stepper Motors

From RepRap
Revision as of 04:36, 31 March 2010 by Cefiar (talk | contribs) (Added stepping angle section)
Jump to: navigation, search

Holding Torque

It is recommended that you need approximately 13.7 N-cm (that is 1400 g-cm or 19.4 oz-in) of Holding Torque or more to avoid issues, although one stepper with less has been used successfully (see below). If in doubt, higher is better.

Stepping Angle

Most stepper motors used for a Mendel have a step angle of 1.8 Degrees. It is something possible to use motors with larger step angles, however for printing to be accurate, they will need to be geared down to reduce the angle moved per step, which may lead to a slower maximum speed.

Size

If going for the smaller NEMA 14 motors, aim for the high torque option. NEMA 14s are neater, lighter and smaller, but can be hard to get hold of with the appropriate holding torque. NEMA 17s are quite easy to get in the specification that Mendel needs, but are bulkier and less neat. NEMA 14s are running near the edge of their envelope: they will get warm. NEMA 17s are well inside what they can do, and will run much cooler.

Suppliers

Below is a list of possible suppliers and motors. Please add to it. If you have built a Mendel successfully with a given motor, remember to put true in the tested field.

Stepper Motors
Vendor (with link) Shipping location Manufacturer Model # Datasheet NEMA (Size) Holding Torque Shaft Tested Additional notes
Motion Control Products Unknown Unknown FL35ST36-1004B FL35ST36-1004B Datasheet 14 ~13.7 N-cm Dual true Used in mendel prototype
Active Robots UK Wantai/Phidget (?) Phidget 3301 3301 Datasheet 14 ~12.3 N-cm 4.9mm true Less Holding Torque than recommended, but has apparently been used successfully
Zapp Automation UK Unknown SY42STH47-1206A SY42STH47-1206A Datasheet 17 ~31.1 N-cm Single true None
Zapp Automation UK Unknown SY42STH47-1684B SY42STH47-1684B Datasheet 17 ~43.1 N-cm Dual true None
Interinar Electronics, LLC US Oriental Motors Vexta PX243M-01AA PX243M-01AA Datasheet 17 15 N-cm Single ? Not strong enough for direct drive extruder, Uses Imperial #4-40 TPI mounting holes instead of M3 metric
Alltronics.com US Lin Engineering 4218L-01-10 4218L-01-10 Datasheet 17 ~53 N-cm 3/16 inch = 4.7625 mm (Round) ? None
Alltronics.com US Lin Engineering 4218L-01-11 4218L-01-11 Datasheet 17 (?) ~53 N-cm ~5 mm = 0.1968 inches (D-Shape) true None
Phidgets.com US Wantai/Phidgets(?) Wantai 42BYGHW811 3303 Datasheet 17 ~47.1 N-cm 4.9mm ? None
SparkFun US Mercury Motor SM-42BYG011 SM-42BYG011 Datasheet 17 23 N-cm 5mm true None
Robot Gear AU Mercury Motor SM-42BYG011-25 SM-42BYG011 Datasheet 17 23 N-cm 5mm true None
Mindkits NZ Mercury Motor SM-42BYG011 SM-42BYG011 Datasheet 17 23 N-cm 5mm true None
AusXMods AU Rugao Xinhe 17H185H-04A Unknown 17 ~43.8 N-cm  ? ? None