Everything in One Place

From RepRap
Jump to: navigation, search

Template:Working Notes

The Everything in One Place Library Scenario

Mister Bunny likes to make RepStraps, but also neat Objects like a Carrot Cake Slicer or a Carrot Lathe like they use commercially to make baby carrots.

And he wants to upload his RepStrap to the same Library as his Carrot Cake Slicer. The same way he only uses one website to upload his videos, and one website for his photos.


Example A

Example B

Argument/Counter Argument

Q:"You can just cut and paste that from the Other Space into the Library, right? It's GPL/Creative Commons/..., so what's the problem."

A:"The problem is that the Library is supposed to be place where RepRap user-developers are supposed to feel welcome. If Joe User is comfortable using an Other Space but doesn't want to use the Library, the Library is broken. Also, cutting and pasting by hand is work. And it introduces Hall of Mirrors issues. And lastly, the role of the Library is to make RepRap users feel welcome to upload, not only RepRap developers."
A2: We've tried that. It's no fun.

Q: "But my design has nothing to do with RepRap. Why post it here if it works as well with any other tool? Why would people even look for it in this library?"

A:Well, if it is printed / laser cut with a RepRap, then it has something to do with RepRap. And it is more fun this way. And because making fun, beautiful, or useful things is the whole point of RepRap. If we do it this way, people help make the wiki beautiful, and it will be fun.
(TODO: not an answer)--Marcus)
Let me put it this way. If we have cad files, text, and images for a quadcopter in a nice wiki page, that acts as bait for a post-mendel with nice wiki page with cad files, cad files, cad files, text, and images. I'm assuming if you do up a new machine, you're not going to document it on the website, especially the cad files, and that's the heart of the project.
Without the heart of the project on the server, we're never going to have decent documentation around here because we won't have a website most people with working repraps care about.--Sebastien Bailard 05:25, 23 May 2011 (UTC)
A2: Helping reprap by uploading photographs or cad files is not compulsory. But it is more fun when people help. When it comes to cad files for new repraps, people in general do not help. No cad files -> no text.

Q: "But this wiki does not support Video/3D-Previews/Rendering STL/large files/tags/newest things/featured things/ratings/flattr/Twitter/Buzz/Facebook/... My design would either not be found or poorly presented."

A:Coming soon! (TODO: not an answer --Marcus) (Give it time. --Sebastien) (I gave it nearly 1.5 years. On the internet that's ages. Marcus)

Library Job

It's the responsibility of the Library Staff and Volunteers to make this easy for Mister Bunny so he can spend more time doing research. (And eating Carrot Cake).